Want to know what truly makes your audience click? A/B testing is your way to find out. By experimenting with different subject lines, designs, and calls to action, you’ll uncover exactly what gets people opening, reading, and buying. This guide shows you how to run tests that turn small tweaks into big wins for your email marketing.
If you’re sending emails without testing them, you’re guessing.
A/B testing, also known as split testing, is how you turn guesswork into insight and insight into performance.
Email A/B testing gives you the tools to understand what works best for your audience. Whether you want more opens, clicks, or conversions, testing helps you improve with data, not assumptions.
This guide breaks down what A/B testing is, how to do it properly, and what to test for the biggest impact.
Email A/B testing involves sending two or more variations of an email often to small portions of your audience to see which version performs better.
Once a winner is determined, based on a chosen metric like open rate or click rate, the winning version is sent to the rest of your list.
It’s a straightforward concept, but the power is in how you apply it. From subject lines to images, send times to CTA buttons, nearly every part of your email can be tested to learn what resonates with your subscribers.
No two audiences are the same. What works for one brand might flop for another. Even within your own list, different segments may respond better to different approaches.
Without testing, you’re relying on instinct. With testing, you’re making decisions based on real behaviour.
A/B testing helps you:
Over time, even small improvements can lead to significant gains.
Here are some of the most common and effective elements to test.
The subject line is your first impression. Test variations in tone, length, emojis, punctuation, urgency, personalisation, and value proposition.
Example:
Version A: “Your Weekly Report Is Ready”
Version B: “Hey Alex, You’ve Got Results Waiting”
Subscribers might engage differently depending on who the email appears to come from. You could try using your brand name versus a real team member, first name only versus full name, or department names like “Support” or “Marketing.”
When you send can be just as important as what you send. Try sending in the morning versus evening, weekday versus weekend, or adjusting by time zones.
Once your email is opened, content becomes the key. Test different headlines, paragraph lengths, formatting, tones of voice, or even storytelling versus a direct offer.
The CTA drives clicks. Test buttons versus text links, different button colours, alternative wording such as “Shop Now” versus “See What’s New,” and where you place your CTA in the email.
Design impacts readability and the way readers move through your email. Try testing an image versus no image, static images versus GIFs, one-column versus multi-column layouts, or swapping hero images.
Test emails with and without first names, dynamic product recommendations, or location-based content to see how personalised elements affect engagement.
Running a successful A/B test involves more than just sending out two versions. Follow these steps to get reliable results.
Start with a clear question. Are you trying to increase opens, clicks, or purchases? Choose one primary metric to measure.
Only change one element between versions. If you change multiple things, you won’t know which had the biggest impact.
Most platforms let you send test versions to a percentage of your list, often 10 to 20 percent. The winning version then goes to the remaining audience.
Wait until you have enough data to confidently call a winner. Ending a test too early can give misleading results.
Look at how both versions performed against your goal. Did one version achieve a higher open rate, more clicks, or more conversions?
Use the insights from your tests to improve future campaigns. A/B testing works best when it’s part of a continuous process.
You won’t always see huge differences. Sometimes the winner only performs slightly better, but over time those small gains add up.
Other times, testing reveals something completely unexpected. For example, a simple plain text email might outperform a beautifully designed one.
That’s the real benefit of testing: it shows you what actually works, not what you assume will.
At Tiger Systems, we help ecommerce and digital brands get the most from their email marketing.
That includes building test-and-learn strategies that drive measurable results.
We’ll help you identify the right opportunities, set up and interpret A/B tests, and refine your campaigns based on real data.
Start a no pressure conversation.